I have to echo Jenni’s choice here, mainly because Fatal Frame is my favorite horror series, so I’ll usually replay something in the series around this time. I’ve been playing a round or two of that several nights a week in October. In addition, while it isn’t fully Halloween-themed, I started a new tradition last year with Dragon Ball: The Breakers, which has its tense and scary moments and (in my opinion) has the best Dead by Daylight-style gameplay. I’m a scaredy cat so being able to run from iconic horror villains like Michael Myers alongside other players helps the atmosphere. The horror game I often go back to at this time of year is Dead by Daylight.